Login

Filter
Filter
Sort by Bestselling
52 Per Page
Chocolate Chip Cookie Dough (12/pack)
$14.00

12 per pack. Instructions to bake on the back of package. 

913 item(s)
+ −
Chocolate Chip Cookie - 4 Pack
$7.95
We make our cookies with real butter, and lots of chocolate chips. Four large cookies to one pack.
+ −
Chocolate Chip Cookie That Suffers From Gigantism
$5.00
Gluten Free
Holy moley, these are so good you'll wonder whether you're suffering from psychosis. They're crispy and chewy both, and they've got absurd amounts of...
999839 item(s)
+ −
Sonora Chocolate Chip Cookie
$4.25
Dairy Free
Our classic chocolate chip cookie made with 100% fresh milled CA-grown Sonora whole wheat flour and Straus family creamery butter. Ingredients: Whole...
+ −
Cal Poly Alumni
6 Gingersnap Cookies
$15.99
Sold by Proof & Gather Baking Company in San Luis Obispo, CA. -Crunchy on the outside and chewy on the inside!
1 item(s)
+ −
Gluten Free Vegan Peanut Butter Cookie Pack
$9.95
Gluten Free
Our gluten free vegan peanut butter cookies are so good non-vegans and gluten free people love them too. We use flax seeds that we grind up to substitute for the eggs and we use real 100% peanut butter. They don't taste like diet cookies.
+ −
Ginger Cookie Dough (12/pack)
$14.00
Ginger cookies ready for you to bake at your lesiure. Great to have on hand for a gathering, or anytime you're craving a sweet treat. 
48 item(s)
+ −
Chocolate Crinkle Cookie
$5.00
Gluten Free
These crinkle cookies are rich and soft and fudgy—kinda like that one cousin of yours. Ingredients: Gluten-free flour blend (Specialty Flour Blend (rice...
999921 item(s)
+ −
Snickerdoodle Cookie - 4 Pack
$7.95
Four snickerdoodle cookies in a pack. We make them from scratch, with real butter.
+ −
Cal Poly Alumni
6 Chocolate Chip Cookies
$15.99

Sold by Proof & Gather Baking Company in San Luis Obispo -This classic chocolate chip cookie is one of our best selling flavors!

5 item(s)
+ −
Walnut Toffee Chocolate Chip Cookie
$4.25

Walnuts and housemade toffee are subtle stars in this chocolate chip cookie.

+ −
Chocolate Chip Sourdough Cookies (2)
$10.00
Our Sourdough chocolate chip cookies weigh 1/4 pound each and feature a crunchy exterior with a gooey, soft center. Topped with coarse sugar and flaky sea...
10 item(s)
+ −
Salted Caramel Chocolate Sourdough cookies (2)
$11.00
Each cookie is crafted with a rich sourdough base, packed to the brim with chocolate chips and caramel bits. Topped with a sprinkle of flaky sea salt,...
10 item(s)
+ −
Smores Sourdough Cookies (2)
$11.00
This soft, chewy cookie is expertly crafted with artisanal sourdough for a unique flavor profile. Topped with luscious marshmallow, toffee bits, chocolate...
10 item(s)
+ −
Sourdough Sugar Cookies
$5.00
Sugary Sweet buttery awesomeness yes with sourdough in it too.  You get a big ol' 3oz cookie with adorable sprinkles that match the season...
14 item(s)
+ −
Vegan Oat and Almond Flour cookie
$4.25

Vegan oat and almond flour cookie with coconut, almonds, and chocolate. This cookie is so moist and delicious, you won't believe it doesn't have any traditional cookie ingredients in it.

+ −
Almond & Oat Flour Chocolate Cookie Dough (12/pack)
$20.00
Vegan
Vegan and low gluten cookies (only made with almond and oat flour), to bake at your leisure. They are chewy and gooey and sooo good! We think you'll love...
89 item(s)
+ −
Ginger cookie
$3.75

This ginger cookie consists of a spicy yet sweet flavor. The chewyness explodes in your mouth while you can find a hint of molasses.

+ −
White Chocolate Sourdough Cookies (2)
$10.00
Each cookie is crafted with tangy sourdough flavor profile, complemented by creamy white chocolate chips and topped with course sugar.    Cookie weighs .25...
10 item(s)
+ −
1 Dozen Sourdough Cookies
$55.00 $48.00
Order will come with 12 individually wrapped Sourdough cookies weighing 5oz or more each, Total order weighs over 4 pounds!  Deep dish style cookies. (3)...
5 item(s)
+ −
Sourdough: Ghiradelli Dutch Cocoa Sourdough Brownie
$6.00

Indulge in the rich and decadent taste of Dutch Cocoa Sourdough Brownies, where luscious Ghirardelli Dutch pressed cocoa meets a unique sourdough twist for a flavor sensation like no other. Baked to perfection, these brownies boast a moist and rich texture that will leave your taste buds craving for more. Elevate your dessert game with these irresistible treats - order now and experience a symphony of flavors in every bite!

 

Brownies are 3oz and sold individually

Our baked goods are made with homemade butter, farm fresh eggs, and sourdough so they are gut friendly!

Try our other sourdough deserts:

Browned Butter Chocolate Chip Sourdough Cookie: https://harvestly.org/bakery/homemade-browned-butter-chocolate-sourdough-cookies/

Baked Sourdough Saigon Cinnamon & Raw Organic Sugar Donuts: https://harvestly.org/bakery/baked-sourdough-saigon-cinnamon-and-raw-sugar-donuts/

7 item(s)
+ −
Peanut butter Chocolate Sourdough cookies (2)
$11.00
I ndulge in our peanut butter chocolate sourdough cookies, each weighing a generous quarter pound for a truly satisfying treat. These handcrafted cookies...
10 item(s)
+ −
Chocolate Chip Sourdough cookies small (6)
$18.00
Our Sourdough chocolate chip cookies feature a crunchy exterior with a gooey, soft center. Topped with coarse sugar and flaky sea salt, they offer a...
10 item(s)
+ −
Sourdough: Homemade Browned Butter Chocolate Chip Sourdough Cookie
$5.00

Indulge in the rich flavor profile and unique texture of our Browned Butter Chocolate Chip Sourdough Cookie. Crafted with artisanal care and homemade butter, these cookies are a true delight for your taste buds. Experience the perfect balance of moistness and delectable sweetness in every bite. Elevate your cookie game with this exquisite creation today!

Made with homeade butter, farm fresh eggs, & sourdough making them gut friendly!

Cookies are 3oz and sold individually.

9 item(s)
+ −
Peanut Butter Chocolate Sourdough Cookies small( 6)
$18.00
These handcrafted cookies feature a perfect harmony of creamy peanut butter and rich chocolate nestled within a tangy sourdough base, topped with a crunchy...
10 item(s)
+ −
Sourdough Campfire Cookie
$5.00
The best smore cookie you ever have. Seriously. A sourdough chocolate chip cookie meets a great camping trip.  Chocolate chip cookie sitting on a graham...
8 item(s)
+ −
Monster Cookie
$4.00

Our rich, decadent, fresh-made-to-order jumbo Monster cookies are 4 oz of dough.

Monster cookies are made with a cookie dough base, mixed with peanut butter, oats, chocolate button candies, chocolate chips.


They are enough to feed two people, but you won't want to share. They are just a little crisp on the outside but gooey and soft in the middle. Cookies are made to order. 

11 item(s)
+ −
Sprinkle Sugar Cookie
$4.00

Our rich, decadent, fresh-made-to-order jumbo sprinkle  sugar cookies are 4 oz of dough.

They are enough to feed two people, but you won't want to share. They are just a little crisp on the outside but gooey and soft in the middle. Cookies are made to order. 

11 item(s)
+ −
Halloween Sourdough Sprinkle cookies small (6)
$18.00
Order comes with 6 individually wrapped cookies  Thick, chewy sourdough cookies stuffed with creamy white chocolate chips and topped with festive...
20 item(s)
+ −
Jumbo Chocolate Chip Cookie
$4.00

Our rich, decadent, fresh-made-to-order jumbo chocolate chip cookies are 4 oz of dough. They are enough to feed two people, but you won't want to share. They are just a little crisp on the outside but gooey and soft in the middle. Cookies are made to order. 

12 item(s)
+ −
Halloween Sourdough Sprinkle cookies (2)
$10.00
Order comes with 2 large cookies  Thick, chewy sourdough cookies stuffed with creamy white chocolate chips and topped with festive Halloween sprinkles!...
20 item(s)
+ −